We've admired them for years, but should we be like South Korea?

Fred Hiat, The Washington Post's editorial page editor, has written a good piece about South Korea's new education crisis. We are reprinting it here in its entirety.

It is interesting to note that most Korean families spend additional private money on Korean hagwon's (essentially after school tutoring centers) in order to help their children qualify for college. This has led to cries of classism there and forced the government to institute new rules that limit, among other things, how late these hagwons can remain open (i.e. not past 10:00 p.m.) If you think our school days are long and wonder how foreign countries do so well, here is one answer.

In South Korea, too many college grads: Fred Hiatt

Published: Wednesday, October 26, 2011, 3:00 AM

SEOUL, South Korea -- Americans who deem South Korea's education system a model (President Barack Obama, among others) might be surprised at one message leaders here are delivering to their youth: Drop out, please.

Well, that may be a slight exaggeration. But South Korea's government has decided that too many people are going to college. It is working to restore the luster of a high school diploma as a stopping point for some and to establish a vocational track for others.
And that has to be sobering for anyone who has assumed that education will be the antidote to the downward-mobility pressures of globalization.

Obama and his education secretary, Arne Duncan, frequently cite South Korea in contrast to America's shortcomings -- the diligence of its students, the commitment of its parents, its success in equipping successive generations to compete.

Pretty much everyone agrees that this East Asian nation's progress, in just half a century, from abject poverty to developed-world prosperity, owes much to its schools and its devotion to schooling. South Korean 15-year-olds rank first in reading and math, and third (behind Finland and Japan) in science, according to the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development. U.S. teens rank 14th, 25th and 17th in the three categories.

Yet South Koreans are deeply unhappy with their system -- to the point that many blame their world-lowest birth rate (1.1 child per woman) on their schools. They complain about an emphasis on memorization, a stifling of creativity, a failure to teach usable English and a weakness in developing leadership skills.

Finding state schools inadequate, parents spend millions on tutoring. Children study in after-school academies, known as "hagwon," until 11 p.m. and beyond. The expense -- Seoul families spend 16 percent of their income on private schooling -- is one reason many parents say they can afford only one child.

The shadow system makes South Koreans worry about their children's health but also, in a society that values equality of opportunity, about unfairness. In response, the government has limited how much hagwon can charge and how many hours they can meet (in theory, not past 10 p.m.)

Because violations are routine, the law allows citizens to report lawbreakers and collect part of the fines for themselves. So now, as the Wall Street Journal recently reported, there are hagwon to teach people how to catch the miscreants.

Much of the pressure arises because South Koreans believe their children must go to college to guarantee themselves a middle-class future. As a result, South Korea has one of the highest college-going rates of any nation -- a category in which, as Obama has complained, the United States has slipped to 12th. More than 60 percent of South Koreans ages 25 to 34 have higher educations, compared with about 40 percent in the United States, and the gap is growing.
But South Korean officials are alarmed that many graduates are not finding jobs -- more than 40 percent in the past year, even though the South Korean economy was doing pretty well. That is why President Lee Myung-bak is promoting alternatives.

Last month, the president urged employers to hire more high school grads and promised, as an example, to hire three into the presidential Blue House this year and three more next year. "Professional footballers just need to be good at kicking balls," Lee said. "They don't need to graduate from Seoul National University."

The government also is investing in vocational schools designed to put young people on a career track without going to college. "Reckless entrance into college," Lee has said, is "bringing huge losses to households and the country alike."

Obama isn't wrong to stress the urgency of improving U.S. education. America's scandal, unlike South Korea's, is the number of poor and minority children consigned to dropout-factory school systems that hollow the promise of class mobility. If South Koreans have put too much emphasis on tests, American schools, allowing so many kids to grow up illiterate, for too long put too little.

But the South Korean experience does suggest that no nation will find an easy answer to the stresses of the global economy, especially as so much of the work of knowledge occupations -- lawyer, editor, radiologist -- proves as outsourceable as building cars or staffing call centers. An educated population will still fare better than an uneducated one. But if you think everything will be OK if we can just be a bit more like, say, South Korea -- well, ask a few South Koreans what they think about that.

One additional note - If you look up hagwons on the internet what you will find is many English speaking  teachers who have been taken advantage of by this private education system; lack of payment, failure to honor terms of contracts, poor living accommodations etc. The Korean government seems concerned about making sure no citizen has an advantage over another by getting too much education.  They don't seem worried about the poor business ethics of the for profit education centers.