What's the difference between the student Longitudinal Data System linking the Department of Education data with the Departments of Labor and Health and Human Services and Arne Duncan's newly announced "United States Education Dashboard"?
Not much. From ed.gov:
The U.S. Department of Education today launched a new website that
provides convenient and transparent access to key national and state
education data, highlighting the progress being made across the country
in every level of the education system and encouraging communities to
engage in a conversation about their schools. The United States
Education Dashboard, available at http://dashboard.ed.gov,
presents important indicators of whether the country is making progress
toward the President's goal – that, by 2020, the United States will
once again have the highest proportion of college graduates in the
world.
"The Dashboard highlights both our successes and challenges while
providing a new level of transparency that is absolutely essential to
our efforts to accelerate student achievement," said U.S. Secretary of
Education Arne Duncan. "We hope communities will use this information to
determine where we need to focus on reforms and investments in
education."
The Dashboard contains a range of cradle-to-career data that furthers
the Department's efforts to provide a more accessible and transparent
view of the country's educational system. On a single webpage, those
interested will be able to view indicators of the nation's performance
in education, gauge their state's progress and see how their state is
performing compared to others. The indicators in the Dashboard focus on
some key outcomes: Are we preparing young children to enter school? Are
students making sufficient progress to graduate from high school and
college? Are they completing college in a timely fashion? Are we
providing an excellent education to all students?
This first version of the Dashboard contains a set of 16 indicators that
range from participation in early childhood education through
completion of postsecondary education, plus indicators on teachers and
leaders, and equity for elementary, secondary, and postsecondary
students. The Dashboard also includes a section, "An Excellent Education
for All," which provides data on whether subgroups are performing
sufficiently. In addition to compiling key data previously reported, the
Dashboard presents two new indicators.
The first shows the number of states that indicated in their 2010 State
Fiscal Stabilization Fund (SFSF) reports that they have school districts
that evaluate their teachers or their principals based in part on
student growth or student achievement. (MEW note: this had to be signed onto when RTTT funding was applied for by the states). The second new indicator shows
how high-poverty school districts are funded compared to low-poverty
districts in their state.
The Dashboard allows users to quickly find information they need and
view it in several different ways. It also allows users to download
customized reports for further analyses.
The Department is committed to continually updating the Dashboard's data
and to enhancing the tools on the website. Indicators will be updated
as new information becomes available, and users are encouraged to
provide comments and feedback on the Dashboard so that usability and
functionality can be enhanced in updates and subsequent versions.
What is the bottom Line? Your student is data mined based on standardized assessments measuring if he/she was taught to the test. It won't measure real knowledge. It will, however, determine if your child's teachers and administrators retain their jobs or are reassigned if they are "too effective". If test scores are too high, look for the "highly effective" teachers reassigned to lower performing classrooms or schools.
Here's a blip from the website:
Reaching the President's goal will require comprehensive education
reforms from cradle to career, beginning with children at birth,
supporting them through high school graduation and postsecondary
education, and helping them to succeed as lifelong learners who can
adapt to the constant changes in the demands of the global economy. Our
youngest children must be in early learning environments that prepare
them for success in kindergarten. We must continue to close the
achievement gaps and ensure that all K-12 students are on track to
graduate from high school ready for college and a career. Once students
enroll in college, we must provide them with financial aid and other
support to help them complete their degrees.
Call me skeptical. I don't believe comprehensive education reforms from the time children are born will make the difference if a child is successful. Innate intelligence, personality, temperament, emotional development, parental involvement, and student desire don't seriously factor into these reforms. And of course, the US government that is currently $16 Trillion in debt can state on this site with sincerity, "we must provide them with financial aid and other
support to help them complete their degrees". With this nanny state mentality comes loss of privacy, individual freedoms and the death of the human spirit. Being data mined leaves students, parents, teachers and administrators little less than cogs in a managed economy.
What planet is Arne Duncan from? It's about time to beam him up and out of the Department of Education.
"...the President's goal will require comprehensive education reforms from cradle to career, beginning with children at birth..."
ReplyDeleteWhat a brave new world this 1984 is.
We must look at all those who support this initiative including the non-profits and venture philanthropists.
ReplyDelete